top of page

How Churches Survive Disputes -- Paul's Instructions in Romans 14

8 minutes ago
20 min read

Your church isn't about you; it's about Jesus.


Bible Study Ideas and Commentary for Romans 14

Paul closes his "rules for Christian living" with one final application: if you're supposed to be humble and put the needs of others before your own, then this means you should care more about the unity of your church than your personal desires -- even if you think you're right. This is very difficult to work out in practice, which is why there are so many churches.

13 Therefore, let us no longer judge one another. Instead decide never to put a stumbling block or pitfall in the way of your brother or sister.

Guess what -- no AI used in writing this post.


Getting Started: Things to Think About

Office Pet Peeves

This week's passage is about dealing with people who have different standards than you do. (Yes, Paul is focusing on the spiritual side of things, but to open a lesson time, it seems to work best to use a lower-impact topic.) A great illustration of this might be your workplace. You spend many hours a day in a space with people who may have very different "behavioral norms" than you do. And some workplaces are more harmonious than others.


What are your biggest office (workplace) pet peeves?


Social media loves this topic. It particularly harps on "microwaving fish" and "keeping your gym shoes under your desk" and "clipping your fingernails in public". What about you? What things drive you the most nuts?


Usually, social media only brings up those things to shame that person into stopping. But for a Bible study, I'd like for you to push into the direction of "how do you handle those behaviors?" or "what do you do to keep the peace in your workplace?".


Yes, sometimes the behavior just needs to stop. And sometimes everyone else is just being a bit overly sensitive. How do you handle that?


Paul has some Christianity-centric thoughts related to this, and they're incredibly practical.


"Agree to Disagree"

We've all heard or used this phrase. I had it come up in a meeting just last week! When have you used this phrase? What were the circumstances, and what was the result?


A bigger question is "why" do we use this phrase? What are the kinds of things that we find it appropriate to agree to disagree?


When I was looking up examples, I found this article: Agree to Disagree Stinks - Say This Instead for Better Work Relationships. Their long-and-short is that "“Agree to disagree” is dismissive, shuts down collaboration, and prevents meaningful solutions." And having read their argument, I buy it! I'm going to make an effort to avoid using that phrase. But I was also quite unimpressed with their alternatives; maybe your group has a good alternative to the phrase "agree to disagree". My ideas are going in the direction of "what do we agree on?" and "what is a conclusion we're both comfortable with?".


In this week's passage, Paul talks about some big disagreements in the Christian life. And you know, "agree to disagree" is not where he goes with it.


Peer Pressure from Christians

This topic gets a little more serious. Have you ever felt peer pressure from someone you looked up to as a Christian? That's one way of reading this week's passage.


Many, many years ago I took a long road trip with some Christian friends. Through one city, I tuned into whatever local grunge station (it was my favorite genre). Much later, I learned that that really offended one of the guys in the car with me. He was a brand new Christian and really only wanted to be listening to Christian music. Multiple lessons from that -- including to work out those details ahead of time if you're taking a long road trip with other people!


Have you ever felt pressured by another Christian to do something you weren't really comfortable doing? Or conversely -- have you ever (even unintentionally) pressured another Christian into doing something they weren't really comfortable with?


This is a big deal to Paul, and having now been in church work for more than 25 years, I understand why. Peer pressure messes with the reputation and unity of a church (as well as the personal relationships that make up a church).


Why Do Churches Tend to Be Homogeneous?

You might remember MLK's famous line that 11:00 Sunday is the most segregated hour of the week. Look around our churches, and that still seems to be the case (though not necessarily due to racial segregation).


Think about your church family. What tends to draw people to your church? What do you have in common? If you know about people who "drift away", what seems to have been a factor in that?


Congregations tend to group ideologically. I think you would find that the people in your church agree about more things than they disagree about -- not just beliefs about Christianity, but about morality and politics and so on.


Why is that?


Frankly, people just prefer to voluntarily spend time with people who think like them. Our culture, our socioeconomics, those things shape how we think. Thus, we gravitate into churches where people look like us and have relatable backgrounds (and act like they like us). (More about this below.)


In other words, once there's enough friction in beliefs and behaviors of church members, one of those church members is likely to move to a church where there is less such friction. (For the record, I'm fine with that. I would much rather a Christian look forward to "going to church" than dread it.)


But in Paul's day, that wasn't an option. There was one church in Rome. So here's my big topic idea: if there were only one church where you live, what do you think it would be like? How do you think it would go?


For logistics alone, I have no doubt it would be impossible. But for discussion's sake, try to imagine it. That should help us see why Paul wrote what he wrote.

This Week's Big Idea: Why We Have So Many Churches

Someone in your group may believe that having so many churches and denominations is a red mark for the unity of the Body of Christ, and they would use this week's chapter to argue that we need to do the hard work of merging churches and denominations.


In case that comes up, I want to give you some more things to think about.


In this week's passage, Paul says that maintaining unity in the Body of Christ is more important that an individual Christian exercising his or her personal viewpoints. So, let's start there: why do we have so many denominations? (If you have people in your group who haven't thought about this, this might be a worthwhile detour.)


Start thinking about how many people would answer "yes" to these questions: Do you believe in God? Do you believe there's only one God? Do you believe in Jesus? Do you believe Jesus is the Son of God? Do you believe faith in Jesus is the only way to be saved? Do you believe the Bible is the Word of God? Do you believe the Bible is inerrant? Do you believe Christians should be baptized? Do you believe in baptism by immersion? Do you believe churches should be autonomous? Do you believe congregations should select their pastors? Do you believe there should be an organ in your sanctuary? And so on. There are thousands of such questions you could come up with. You're going to answer "yes" to some and "no" to others and "I'm not really worried about that" to the rest.


Here's how I put this in a class I taught on the subject many years ago:

Think of our beliefs as a series of circles. We all can locate ourselves somewhere in them. Eventually, we will find a circle where we say, “I’m no longer comfortable associating with someone in this circle.” That is the limit of our orthodoxy. We determine those limits by virtue of the authorities we talked about earlier. What is truly orthodox? God knows, and I believe He has given us what we need to make that determination, but we certainly can’t agree on very much of that!

To help illustrate that, I created this diagram:



The places people answer "yes" and "no" and "no big deal" is why we have denominations.


You might say, "But Paul is talking about social matters in Romans 14, not matters of Christian orthodoxy! Talking about our Christian beliefs is taking Paul's words too far."


Well, that's my point. You might think that, but somebody else might think the opposite. You might think that "believer's baptism by immersion" is a non-negotiable belief when it comes to forming a church, but what's the big deal if some of the church members, say, like to party with drinking once a week. But somebody else might wonder what's the big deal with baptism, but we really need to clamp down on our congregation's behavior. How easily will you two coexist in a church?


Let's talk about behavior (which is Paul's focus this week). Let's further develop the topic I just mentioned. Consider:

  • Christians should not drink alcohol

  • having one drink is okay

  • "drinking" is okay

  • getting drunk is okay

I'm going to assume that everyone in your group agrees that getting drunk is not okay (because the Bible clearly says that). But I'm also going to assume that there will be some disagreement on where "the line" is otherwise. And furthermore, I'm going to assume that some group members will be more emphatic about the importance of that line.


And if you push this really hard, I'm also sure that you can create some very hurt feelings and some big problems in your group! (Note: Paul is going to tell us how to handle these kinds of situations and disagreements.)


And that's the point of my "big idea". Not only do Christians disagree about things, but Christians also disagree about how important those disagreements are. That's why we have to approach disagreements in churches with much humility.


Bonus Big Idea: The "Weak" and the "Strong"

Lifeway tried to avoid this topic by starting their passage in verse 5, but we shouldn't (not if we want to understand chapter 14). Paul starts the chapter with:

1 Welcome anyone who is weak in faith, but don’t argue about disputed matters. 2 One person believes he may eat anything, while one who is weak eats only vegetables.

"Disputed matters" can also mean "differing opinions". Paul is not talking about "Christian orthodoxy" (i.e., the correct beliefs related to Christianity) -- Paul would never compromise proper biblical beliefs. Paul is talking about matters in which Christians can disagree.

  • Should churches have pews or chairs?

  • Should those pews have cushions? And what color?

  • Should churches have organs or guitars?

  • Should Christians give 10% or more or less?

Aha! You might say, "But wait! Pews are very important! (or The tithe is very important!)" And you've just illustrated Paul's point. You're now disputing whether or not a matter is disputable. Oy vey!


[Note: this is why studying the Bible is so important. If we don't know God's Word, anybody can tell us that any topic is a "hill to die on" or not, and we wouldn't know otherwise.]


And that's gets us into an interesting part of the passage: who is "weak" and who is "strong"? There is no firm consensus on this. Common proposals:

  • "weak" means "new in the faith"; "strong" means "mature in the faith"

  • "weak" means "their faith is itself weak; it is ineffective in helping them deal with questions of conduct"; "strong" means a robust faith

  • "weak" means "rigid and wooden"; "strong" means "able to see other points of view"


The specific situation Paul illustrates -- one person is comfortable eating meat, another is only comfortable eating vegetables -- is related to everyone's favorite "meat sacrificed to idols" from 1 Corinthians 8 (we covered Paul's application in 1 Corinthians 9). In the pagan Roman empire, a lot of butchers offered their meats to an idol before selling them. Paul knew that because the false god didn't actually exist, it didn't actually matter that the meat had been offered to it. But to a new Christian who was trying to make a break from his old life, or who still had confusion about the "old gods of the Romans", eating such meat could make them very uncomfortable. Their "cleanest break" would be to eat vegetables. (Because what false god would want to be offered vegetables?)


Paul calls those Christians "weak". And those "weak" Christians might complain to the "strong" Christians that it isn't right for them to eat meat sacrificed to idols. Paul tells the "strong" Christians not to make a big deal out of it. We'll go into the why in our study below.


But here's the fun application that would get you and me anybody else into more trouble than it's worth (so don't go there) -- in the "disputable matters" I listed above, which side would be considered "weak", and which would be considered "strong"?


(The answer, according to Paul's example: the person who is willing to fight over the matter is the "weak" one. Uh oh!)

Where We Are in Romans

We're just about done. Only one more lesson after this one!

  1. Christian Living (12:1-15:13)

    1. Our attitude toward God (12:1-2)

    2. Our attitude toward other Christians (12:3-16)

    3. Our attitude toward non-Christians (12:17-21)

    4. Our attitude toward rulers (13:1-7)

    5. Our attitude toward all people (13:8-14)

    6. Liberty, peace, love, and unity (14:1-15:13)

  2. Conclusion, Future Plans, and Greetings (15:14-16:27)


Paul has established that Christians should put other Christians before themselves and try to live at peace with everyone. This includes in the church. So, Paul ends this section with some very practical advice for helping a church glorify God.


And it's really simple: Your church isn't about you. Your church is about Jesus.


If you insist on putting yourself and your "rights" above everyone else and stirring up trouble so you can have your way, you've missed the whole purpose of the church.

Part 1: When Disagreement Leads to Division (Romans 14:5-8)

5 One person judges one day to be more important than another day. Someone else judges every day to be the same. Let each one be fully convinced in his own mind. 6 Whoever observes the day, observes it for the honor of the Lord. Whoever eats, eats for the Lord, since he gives thanks to God; and whoever does not eat, it is for the Lord that he does not eat it, and he gives thanks to God. 7 For none of us lives for himself, and no one dies for himself. 8 If we live, we live for the Lord; and if we die, we die for the Lord. Therefore, whether we live or die, we belong to the Lord.

In verses 1-4, Paul basically says "don't play god over somebody else's Christian choices".


Goodness, has this caused a brouhaha! You will hear the "liberal Christianity" crowd use this passage to say that "if that Christian wants to be a homosexual, that's their business" or "if that Christian wants to have a sex change operation, that's between them and God; you stay out of it".


What is the problem with that argument?


For Paul's illustrations, it really doesn't make a Christian difference if a person is a vegetarian or not. And in verse 5, it really doesn't make a Christian difference whether a church thinks they should worship on Sunday or Saturday (or observe Christmas or not, etc.). (And I'm serious about that -- is a church within their rights before God to choose not to celebrate the birth of Jesus on December 25?) They are disputable matters.


[Look up the term "adiaphora" and you can find plenty of historic books written on this subject.]


Is a person's sexual behavior disputable? I would say no -- because the Bible clearly speaks to sexual behavior. The Bible does not clearly speak to modern diets (beyond that we should treat our bodies well). That's what makes one matter disputable and the other not.


[But I remind you -- that's why I spent so much time above establishing that professing Christians do not agree on what is disputable and what is not. That's why these discussions are so difficult (and why there are so many churches).]


The Lifeway material offers an excellent illustration: when the early church debated the Jewish "kosher diet". Read Acts 10 and Galatians 2 to refresh yourself on the topic. The Jewish Christians were expected to relax their dietary expectations to accommodate the new Gentile Christians . . . because God told them to. They could feel free to continue in their own diets as they desired, but they could not impose their diet on the new Gentile Christians. Over time, this seemed to drive a wedge between Peter and the Gentile Christians, and Paul had to confront him publicly. We studied that: Paul Called Peter Out - a study of Galatians 2:11-21.


In Galatians 2, Paul could point to Peter's own direct experience with God to explain why Peter was wrong to dissociate from the Gentile Christians.


How do we know today what's a disputable matter in church or not?


As I hope I've illustrated, this isn't always an easy question. Two weeks ago, we talked about Paul's advice in Romans 12:

3 For by the grace given to me, I tell everyone among you not to think of himself more highly than he should think. Instead, think sensibly, as God has distributed a measure of faith to each one. 4 Now as we have many parts in one body, and all the parts do not have the same function, 5 in the same way we who are many are one body in Christ and individually members of one another. 6 According to the grace given to us, we have different gifts: If prophecy, use it according to the proportion of one’s faith; 7 if service, use it in service; if teaching, in teaching; 8 if exhorting, in exhortation; giving, with generosity; leading, with diligence; showing mercy, with cheerfulness.

We're already supposed to default to the attitude of being humble and putting everyone else in our church above ourselves. Then we remember that God has placed gifts in every church family. When there's a dispute in your church, may your leaders lead graciously, may your discerners give clear advice, and may your encouragers hold your church family together through the process.


Does that make sense? There's no sense in giving some clear every-situation process because every situation is unique (and every church is unique). If you are all fully committed to the honor of the Lord, you can have faith that you will work through whatever disagreement you face.


Because again -- it's not about us. It's about Jesus.


The way I apply this verse is this:

  • Does your church's decision/behavior win non-Christians toward Jesus, or does it push non-Christians away from Jesus?

  • Does your church's decision/behavior help your members grow in their discipleship to Jesus, or does it confuse them or stunt their spiritual growth?

Those answers are not always clear, but I have found more often than not that they are clearer than we might have first guessed.


Our church isn't about us. It's about Jesus.

Part 2: Look in the Mirror First (Romans 14:9-12)

9 Christ died and returned to life for this: that he might be Lord over both the dead and the living. 10 But you, why do you judge your brother or sister? Or you, why do you despise your brother or sister? For we will all stand before the judgment seat of God. 11 For it is written, As I live, says the Lord, every knee will bow to me, and every tongue will give praise to God. 12 So then, each of us will give an account of himself to God.

The first passage that comes to mind to me on this topic is from the Sermon on the Mount:

Matt 7:1 Do not judge, so that you won’t be judged. 2 For you will be judged by the same standard with which you judge others, and you will be measured by the same measure you use. 3 Why do you look at the splinter in your brother’s eye but don’t notice the beam of wood in your own eye? 4 Or how can you say to your brother, ‘Let me take the splinter out of your eye,’ and look, there’s a beam of wood in your own eye? 5 Hypocrite! First take the beam of wood out of your eye, and then you will see clearly to take the splinter out of your brother’s eye.

Jesus isn't talking about church-building in His sermon, so His primary point is about a Christian's honest view of self -- we are all sinners. God is the only righteous Judge.


Paul is talking about church-building, so His primary point is about a Christian's honest view of other Christians -- we are all loved by God. God is the only merciful Savior.


They are different sides of the same coin. We are all sinners who can only be saved by grace. God is Judge and Savior. So both Paul and Jesus tell us the same thing: because we are sinners saved by grace, let's focus on telling others how they can be saved, and let's let God be their Judge.


[Note: Paul quotes Isaiah 45, and it reminds us that God will judge everyone. Make no mistake.]


This goes back to what Paul has been saying about urgency. Life is short; Jesus is coming back; what's more important: your "being right" or that person's salvation and walk with Jesus?


[Another note: remember that Paul is talking about disputable matters, not fundamental truths of our faith. We're supposed to "die on the hill" of matters of salvation; otherwise we're letting that wrong belief lead that person astray, and maybe to hell.]


How do you think this attitude helps a church be more united?


Does Paul allow you to stop behaving like this if the other people in your church are not following these instructions?

Part 3: Don't Tear Each Other Down . . . (Romans 14:13-18)

13 Therefore, let us no longer judge one another. Instead decide never to put a stumbling block or pitfall in the way of your brother or sister. 14 I know and am persuaded in the Lord Jesus that nothing is unclean in itself. Still, to someone who considers a thing to be unclean, to that one it is unclean. 15 For if your brother or sister is hurt by what you eat, you are no longer walking according to love. Do not destroy, by what you eat, someone for whom Christ died. 16 Therefore, do not let your good be slandered, 17 for the kingdom of God is not eating and drinking, but righteousness, peace, and joy in the Holy Spirit. 18 Whoever serves Christ in this way is acceptable to God and receives human approval.

"No longer" suggests that this kind of judgment was common in the early churches. And it would make sense, especially considering the early debates between Jews and Gentiles about kosher diets. It is rather common for humans to see "different" as "something to condemn".


Note that this works both ways --

  • the "strong" in faith should stop pushing the "weak" for their weak faith;

  • the "weak" in faith should stop thinking that they have the right to complain about the "strong" in faiths' behavior.


However, the "strong" in faith is the better equipped to accommodate.

  • The "weak" in faith can't get past the "meat sacrificed to idols" and is greatly offended by anyone who eats meat sacrificed to an idol.

  • The "strong" in faith has understood that meat is meat because "false gods" are no gods, but it shouldn't be a big deal for the "strong" not to flaunt their willingness to eat meat sacrificed to idols.


Why? Because that "strong" Christian should be putting other Christians first. It's possible that the "strong" Christian doesn't realize the conflict he's creating; but once he knows, he should back down immediately and put the needs of others first.


And why again? Because the Christian life isn't about eating and drinking -- it's about righteousness, peace, and joy.


This again can be traced to the Sermon on the Mount:

Matt 6:31 So don’t worry, saying, ‘What will we eat?’ or ‘What will we drink?’ or ‘What will we wear?’ 32 For the Gentiles eagerly seek all these things, and your heavenly Father knows that you need them. 33 But seek first the kingdom of God and his righteousness, and all these things will be provided for you.

There, Jesus is focused on helping potential-Christians get over the fears of what they might lose if they choose to follow Jesus. Paul, on the other hand, is helping already-Christians remember what's important. And to both groups: God's righteousness is a much greater treasure than any consumed good.


This is what it looks like to put other church members first.


Yes, it can get hurtful and frustrating because yes, these same rules should apply to those other church members! But from Jesus and also from Paul, God's standard for you does not change based on how the people around you behave.


Here's where you need to be careful. I think you should identify examples of these "stumbling blocks" that would make sense to your unique group. [Note: this is a different word for "stumble" than Romans 9:32. That word is extreme, something you can't recover from. This word is a regular "obstacle", like the toy left in the hall; it'll trip you up, but you can recover from the fall.]


The one that I default to is "drinking alcohol". Does the Bible say that you can't ever drink alcohol? Certainly not -- wine is wine, even if it was much more diluted in those days. But the Bible also says you shouldn't ever get drunk (like, for example, Ephesians 5:18). So, how do you know when you're drunk? Are you going to let the government's "legal limit" establish that for you?


Paul gives you yet another factor to consider: the people around you. You've probably heard some phrase about how different people "hold their liquor". If you can "safely" drink more than the person next to you, might your drinking cause them to have one too many? And before you say "that's on them!" realize that Paul is very clearly saying "no, that's on you!". And what about the recovering alcoholic who really, really needs to stay away from alcohol completely. What are you doing to that person by drinking in front of them?


What I think Paul is saying, which is how I've chosen to live, is "the safest, most conscientious move is to not drink at all". Of course, you can say "I'll just drink in the privacy of my own home". And okay, hard to argue with that. But who sees you buy the alcohol at the store? Who sees it in your cabinet when they visit your house? ("Sheesh -- I'll just order it from Amazon and keep the generic packaging on it." And so our technological world makes it easier and easier to indulge ourselves.)


But let's keep going:

  • what about smoking marijuana (assuming it's legal)?

  • what about gambling (assuming it's legal)?

  • what about engaging in a dangerous hobby (assuming it's legal)?

  • and so on


[Note: the "assuming it's legal" is important. If it's not legal, don't do it. See last week's lesson on Romans 13.]


What are the behaviors that fall into this "stumbling block" category that we need to care what other people think?


To cite 1 Corinthians -- that behavior might be "permissible", but is it "beneficial"? As a Christian, we're not supposed to think just about ourselves.

Part 4: . . . But Build Each Other Up (Romans 14:19-20)

19 So then, let us pursue what promotes peace and what builds up one another. 20 Do not tear down God’s work because of food. Everything is clean, but it is wrong to make someone fall by what he eats.

In other words, "being right" isn't always the most important thing.


By this point in the letter, this should make complete sense, and you shouldn't have anything to argue against.


"Builds up" is a construction phrase, and it's one of the reason why "house of the Lord" is a phrase that gets used alongside "body of Christ". As a church, we are a "spiritual house" being built by the Holy Spirit (see 1 Peter 2). By our actions, we can "help" the Holy Spirit build our church up, or we can interfere and tear that work down.


To use Paul's "body" imagery, when one member of the body suffers, the entire body suffers. (See 1 Cor 12.)


Two very serious questions for your group to consider:

  • is there anything divisive going on in your church right now that this passage speaks to? and what can you do to help your church leaders address it?

  • is there any behavior you promote that tends to be controversial with other members, and what are you going to do to "put a sock in it"?


But I really want to keep going to one more verse.

Closing Thoughts: Romans 14:21-23

21 It is a good thing not to eat meat, or drink wine, or do anything that makes your brother or sister stumble. 22 Whatever you believe about these things, keep between yourself and God. Blessed is the one who does not condemn himself by what he approves. 23 But whoever doubts stands condemned if he eats, because his eating is not from faith, and everything that is not from faith is sin.

I believe this is one of the most challenging passages in the Bible, and it makes us think long and hard about whatever answer you might have given to the questions above.


First, realize the important difference between "It is a good thing not to eat meat" and "It is not a good thing to eat meat". Eating meat is fine, but sometimes not eating it is better.


Paul tells you to "keep your beliefs to yourself". As earlier, some have tried to make this mean that Christians should never ever never tell another person how they should act or think. NO! Paul very specifically says "these things", meaning the things we've been talking about in this lesson -- the disputable matters.


Don't go around wearing out everyone with your pet beliefs about certain behaviors. You're making the church about you, not about Jesus. But do tell other people how they can be saved!


I have a couple of very strong convictions that are not shared by many people in my church. I could raise a lot of fuss and cause a lot of hurt by parading them around. Paul, wisely, tells me not to do that. And the same goes for you.


But the hardest truth is found in verse 23. Everything that is not from faith is sin.


Think about the answers you gave to the questions above. Do you believe so strongly in that opinion that you think the Holy Spirit would be on board with it? Or are you taking the "easier to ask for forgiveness than permission" approach to the Christian life?


To use Paul's illustration, if you aren't convinced in your heart that God says it's okay to eat meat sacrificed to an idol, you shouldn't do it. And to be very clear, it's not just a neutral opinion -- it's either from faith, or it's sin.


That's very, very strong.


But why does Paul make sure a strong statement here? Because acting outside of your faith always leads to more sin. A Christian should always strive to cling to the good and stay as far away from the evil as we possibly can.


Let that be a warning or motivation to you.


Your behavior affects more than just you, and you need to care about the others in your church.


I also think it's a good rule to add to our list of good rules from Romans:

12:21 Do not be conquered by evil, but conquer evil with good.
14:23 everything that is not from faith is sin.

Comments


bottom of page